You are viewing an old version of this page. View the current version.

Compare with Current View Page History

« Previous Version 276 Next »


Pages that need work have an incomplete tag.
Pages that need to be deleted have a deleteme tag.
Pages that need to be reviewed have an review tag.
Pages that have problems with the citations at the bottom have the citations-incomplete tag.


review -> review + review-one -> review + review-two -> No tags
significant changes -> review or incomplete


Run spider with new changes.


Incomplete pages in C++ use their own incomplete-cpp tag.
Incomplete pages in Java use their own incomplete-java tag.


Pages now have tags to indicate the status of their corresponding checker in Compass Rose.
Complete rules are tagged rose-complete.
Partially complete rules are tagged rose-partial.
Rules that simply cannot be enforced by Rose are tagged rose-nonapplicable.
Rules that could be easily done in Rose are tagged rose-possible.


It might also be worth giving these another look.


I've looked at some of the C rules and recommendations, and here are my
recommendations (smile) for copying them across to C++.

DCL05-A - OK more-or-less as is.
DCL06-A - OK more-or-less as is.
DCL07-A - needs rethinking for C++.
DCL09-A - not appropriate for C++ because of ERR00-A.
DCL10-A - needs some reworking for C++ (note that ISO/IEC 14882-2003
does not use the term "variadic function").
DCL11-A - ditto.
DCL12-A - perhaps needs reworking for C++.
DCL30-C - needs reworking for C++.
DCL32-C - what are the C++ requirements on identifier length?
DCL33-C - not applicable?
DCL34-C - OK more-or-less as is.
DCL35-C - OK more-or-less as is, but need to change printf's in CS.
DCL36-C - needs reworking for C++.

EXP00-A - OK more-or-less as is.
EXP01-A - needs different examples.
EXP03-A - needs different examples.
EXP04-A - OK more-or-less as is.
EXP07-A - needs rethinking for C++.
EXP08-A - perhaps already covered by OBJ30-C.
EXP09-A - OK more-or-less as is.
EXP34-C - perhaps covered by DAN34-C.
EXP35-C - this appears to require some rethinking anyway.
EXP36-C - needs some thought for C++.

INT00-A - needs reworking for C++.
INT07-A - needs reworking for C++.
INT30-C - needs reworking for C++.
INT35-C - needs reworking for C++.
INT37-C - needs reworking for C++.

That's as far as I got.

By "OK more-or-less as is" I mean that it can be copied over as it is
but the references to C and the C Standard clearly must be changed to
C++.


When you copy this rule over to the C++ side:

FIO34-C. Use int to capture the return value of character IO functions

Be sure to add something about istream::get() which return int values, not char values.


  • No labels